General Topic
PC gone mad
Linda C10-Jul-23 02:44 pm
A Melbourne school has bought in a puffer jacket for school children. Great except for one thing. On one arm they have the Aboriginal Flag which is fine but on the other arm they have the Gay Pride Flag which is onerous. Where is the Australian Flag - NO WHERE TO BE SEEN.
Why bring this issue into our primary schools. Admittedly the puffer jacket is optional at $90 odd dollars but would have been great for the kids as it is so cold in winter down there but making it a political statement for a minority group is just not on and they are not allowed to remove the flag. So much for choice.
As I said the Aboriginal flag on one sleeve and the Australian flag on the other or side by side etc. would be fine and I see nothing wrong with that but to put a flag on a children's clothing which is about a lifestyle choice in a lot of cases is so wrong.
Kids are now being told not to use gender identities, have transgender and others in their classrooms reading stories to them, allowing men who claim to be women go into girls toilets and change rooms - WAKE UP!!!! Sure there are decent people amongst these groups but it is also another avenue to paedophiles for gain access to our children.
When will this all stop.
Children are being manipulated, women are being marginalised again and it seems these WOKE people think it is great. WHY I ask.
Your opinion on this new societal issues.
Comments
  • Mariaj
    I would have thought a school name badge would be more appropriate for children
    ·
    • Peter T 100083
      PC Can go jump! I do not pander to the BS! Truth hurts some but some need to wake up@
      ·
      • APB
        This one is still up there at the top so well done
        ·
        • Sue 834245
          I agree with you, why Primary School? Is it because they are young and impressionable? Australia is multicultural but why just focusing on these minorities groups? Remember, the no result for the ‘Voice’ Referendum!
          ·
          • The ghost
            It says we are still convicts and colonists of the past, not the true proud nation we are.
            ·
            • Linda C
              Some English still view us as colonialists but really most of us are or our ancestors were immigrants. They built our nation, went to war to protect it and we should be proud of them and continue with the traditions. England was a big part of this and the Union Jack recognizes this history. I am not a monarchist but I do recognize the history. Unfortunately, with all the woke PC and put downs the Australian people have experienced especially in the past 10 years or so, our people have lost the pride in the nation and have become aggressive, whingers, don't won't to work, self indulgent, arrogant you name it. Sad to see. A new flag will never change these attitudes.
              ·
          • Grommie
            NZ tried to change its flag recently spent $27 million and got a no from a referendum. NZ and Aust flags have many similarities
            ·
            • View all 7 replies
            • Linda C
              There are a few flags that look similar to ours. When I went to the Kennedy Center in Washington back in the early 90's I could not pick our Aussie flag out of the lot of them. However, I do not think it should be changed.
              ·
            • Chosen
              Yeah Australia copied ours/NZ and then also say they were the first creator and maker of the Pavlova.
              ·
            • Linda CChosen
              Get over it. We could not care less who created the Pavlova whether us or you. Does it really matter.
              ·
            • ChosenLinda C
              Yes it is a major international incident and one that must be resolved. I and I think the whole nation just cannot stop thinking about it. Maybe it would best to get the United Nations, Nato or one of the large International organisations involved in order to resolve and correct. Agreed ????? Ho, ho, ho.
              ·
            • Linda CChosen
              lol Yes some people do take it too far. Ridiculous. It is just a sugary sweet dessert.
              ·
            • ChosenLinda C
              Laced with KIWI fruit all over the top. Yum, yum.
              ·
            • Linda CChosen
              And popular at Christmas Dinners
              ·
          • Grommie
            now it's gingerbread people (not men) in the parliament cafe in Canberra
            ·
            • Linda C
              Not just parliament. PC stupidity in full regalia.
              ·
          • The ghost
            Minorities have the power and claim discrimination if questioned. I think the Aussie flag is outdated and ugly, maybe it should be changed.
            ·
            • View all 5 replies
            • Linda C
              Our ancestors fought wars and many died under this flag. Nothing wrong with it and it is not ugly. Why people have to keep changing traditions to suit them is beyond me. Some PC person or group comes out and says we don't agree with this or that and weak governments bend to their will.
              ·
            • The ghostLinda C
              I don’t like the cross in the corner WW2 showed how much that counted when needed, I have had a lot to do with training in the armed forces and have respect for them. We need more identification as Australians and colonials.
              ·
            • Chosen
              Yes I think you should change your/Aussie flag as it copies ours/NZ flag.
              ·
            • The ghostChosen
              Yep and they are both crap
              ·
            • Linda C
              Why do people persist in changing our traditions. Soon we will have none left. I personally love our flag. Family members have fought and died under this flag. It is not ugly, outdated as you say.
              ·
          • jason M 1009337
            The world will still turn...men in girls changing rooms is way out of line though
            ·
            • kyson
              for reel
              ·
              • Pat C 618241
                Aren't we hammering this "mode" a little too often. There is an old saying "This too will pass".
                ·
                • Linda C
                  This was posted a year ago.
                  ·
              • Glenice L 1244113
                Sometimes, I think the only way to combat distastefulness, is through showing and showering LOVE and RIGHTEOUSNESS. If more and more persons were always trying to show how best and decent to live, maybe the "other ideas" wouldn't have to be so prevalent. That jacket invention could have been thought of long ago as the cold weather warranted it. Perhaps the greater love could add best warm gloves, hats and boots or invent hand and toe warmers than warm up in cold temperatures etc. After buying/owning such a jacket, I could be one to put a sticker over any patch or tear on the thing🤣
                ·
                • Chosen
                  Am surprised the flag was frilly.
                  ·
                  • kathy b 656074
                    One World Order is the goal of international elitists.
                    ·
                    • Katzeye
                      Yes you are right
                      ·
                  • Sandy G 969046
                    Paedophiles have always had access to our children and very, very few of them were transgender. They were priests, coaches, family friends.... and you can always buy a badge with the Australian flag on it and sew it to the jacket.
                    ·
                    • View all 7 replies
                    • Linda C
                      Agree. As I stated, people now dress as transgenders to get access. Another avenue of access. As for putting the Australian flag on the jacket I think you will find this is against school policy or is what I found in schools my children went to. You had to follow the rules. I know all about paedophiles. My mother was in an orphanage where a priest always took the 12 year old girls for a ride in his car. My mother and her sisters never talked about their time in the orphanage other than a couple of silly things and one said you would not believe us if we told you. Protection of our children must come first above and beyond all this PC that is going on these days. I could care less what adults do but I do care if these ideas are pressed onto impressionable minds. Once a child reaches 18 they are old enough to vote, to fight a war, drive a car etc. so I think old enough to decide their lives. Lets leave the little ones alone.
                      ·
                    • roger b 167654Linda C
                      They're secondary school students, so hardly 'little' ones. I dare say quite a few would be old enough to drive, so as you say 'old enough to decide their lives'
                      ·
                    • Linda Croger b 167654
                      Their ages range between 13 &18
                      ·
                    • roger b 167654roger b 167654
                      Yes, exactly - a few old enough to drive and some old enough to vote
                      ·
                    • Linda Croger b 167654
                      Only the 18 year old students
                      ·
                    • roger b 167654Linda C
                      The 16 year olds can drive a car
                      ·
                    • Linda Croger b 167654
                      not here
                      ·
                  • Gunter L
                    You ask: "When will this all stop?" The answer is: "Never".
                    ·
                    • pam rae
                      Hi Sean f, ty, have a great fun time on site....
                      ·
                      • Sean f 1047130
                        Everything has become so political; a local municipality in s ontario Canada made a policy to not fly the rainbow flag as it would set a precedent for any other groups (even extremists) to have a democratic right to have their flags flown. Guess what? yep they got so much flack for doing it and have been called white-extremists for some reason. I wonder if when purchasing, they could have made it a choice, and where 1 dollar from every lgbtq2+* flag added, it goes directly to a social services organization in the community (a potential win win idea...no?).
                        ·
                        • Linda C
                          Thank you everyone for your comments and views. It was very interesting to see how people reacted and assumed in some cases. I hope our children go through life happily and safe and accepted.
                          ·
                          • View all 3 replies
                          • Lee b 979050
                            Right on sister
                            ·
                          • Teri 1282723
                            And I know I grew as a person. Thank you for challenging me.
                            ·
                          • Linda CTeri 1282723
                            Any time. lol
                            ·
                        • boy blunder
                          they shouldn't have any more than the school logo on them, all these other logos could be added as a personal choice,
                          ·
                          • Jytte (Auckland, NZ)
                            Being gay, bisexual etc is not a lifestyle choice. Pedophiles? Wow you are very misinformed and prejudice. However, the Aboriginal flag and the Australian flag is what should be on the puffer jacket.
                            ·
                            • View all 14 replies
                            • Linda C
                              Never meant to say it was a lifestyle choice per se. I have many cousins and friends who are gay and realise it is just who they are. My main fear is the paedophiles who use any means to be near children. I do not think I am misinformed about them and far from being prejudiced as I had a parent who was abused, a cousin who was abused and a number friends who were abused all at ages under 12 let alone acquaintances who have spoken to me about their experiences. I also stated that the Aboriginal flag and the Australian flag should both be on the jacket.
                              ·
                            • Jytte (Auckland, NZ)Linda C
                              My last sentence I was agreeing with you. Being transgender etc is not something someone normally chooses as there is so much stigma etc that comes with it. I have a friend and an ex who were raped so I'm aware of issues in relation to abuse and kids. I also have a friend who is trans so I'm aware of trans issues too. Being trans still does not mean that every transgender person is a pedophile!!!
                              ·
                            • Linda CJytte (Auckland, NZ)
                              I never said they were. I said paedophiles will use any means to get close to kids not that transgenders are paedophiles.
                              ·
                            • PEN15Linda C
                              I’m actually really sick of the ‘pedophile in the public toilet’ argument against trans people using restrooms. The ridiculously overwhelming majority of pedophiles attack kids they already know, and they don’t do it in public places. Victims of this kind of abuse are significantly safer in public than they are at their own homes, the homes of people they know, churches, scout camps etc. They groom before they abuse. It makes it easier for them to abuse. But let me indulge this tired, irrational and insulting argument for a moment. Let’s just say a male pedophile decides to pose as a trans woman so they can attend a public restroom in order to get close to a child to offend against them. Now unless they’re very feminine looking to begin with or particularly skilled at passing as a woman they are probably going to get noticed. Do they want to be noticed when they’re just about to offend? I doubt it. They would be better off dressing as a man and entering the male restroom to offend there. Boys are victims as well as girls, and would be more at threat from a pedophile who wanted to offend in a restroom without drawing attention to themselves. Perhaps we should just ban all men from male public restrooms to protect the boys. Or maybe boy victims don’t matter as much as girl victims to this particular argument? Most parents accompany their children to public restrooms. But even if the child was alone in there, another person could enter at anytime and intervene, it’s a public place. There are many more points I could make here, but the main takeaway is this is an extremely unlikely scenario. Any pedophile who wants to stay under the radar is not going to draw attention to themselves in any way. And where is the data or statistics on this? Where are the reports of this happening? Plenty of reports of trans women being harassed and attacked in public restrooms, but I can’t find any reports of sexual assaults against children from a pedophile disguised as a trans woman in the same place. Statistically if you want to keep your child safe from predators, don’t leave them in a church group, a scout group or alone with an adult who has groomed them. Supervise them and do surprise checks if they are playing with Uncle Wayne in another room. Educate them and yourselves on the signs of grooming. People you know danger is waaaaay more dangerous than stranger danger, but teach them what to do if approached by a stranger in a public place. This ridiculous argument that people keep bringing up is not based in any real world examples or any likely examples given the risk of exposing the pedophile. It’s just fear mongering perpetrated by bigots to encourage division. It’s then taken on and repeated by people who obviously have no compassion toward trans women or any critical thinking skills of their own or they’d be screaming to outlaw priests rather than outlawing trans inclusive bathrooms if they really wanted to protect children from pedophiles.
                              ·
                            • roger b 167654PEN15
                              One could argue to avoid pedophile attacks there should be no churches near schools!
                              ·
                            • PEN15roger b 167654
                              One could indeed argue that. It would make much more sense when your argument is pedophiles will use any means necessary to get close to kids.
                              ·
                            • Linda CPEN15
                              I warned/educated my children as did my Mother as her sisters were abused in an orphanage. I agree there are many places children both male and female are abused and in many cases by people they know such as grandfather, dad, brother, uncle, friend, neighbour etc. Horrible as it sounds. Paedophiles dressed as women have already been caught in girls dressing rooms/toilets. I never said transgenders did this. I think everyone is sick of having to keep saying NO to allowing such a risk because certain people do not want to offend a few. If I am keeping my children safe I could care less how many adults I offend.
                              ·
                            • Teri 1282723Linda C
                              That's so right!! It's not 'stranger danger' we need to teach kids about NEARLY as often as it's 'don't ever be alone in a room with uncle/grandpa/daddy/brother. We need to teach our children - at appropriate ages, of course - that girls are always going to be vulnerable, no matter their age, and boys and men are also vulnerable - mostly until adulthood, but there are Jeffrey Dahmers out there and if they're LGBTQ+, to always watch out who they go home with. SO many situations go horribly wrong. In the 5 mins. or so on this message, I can think of at least a dozen people who were sexually abused by relatives. Not one of them by a stranger or neighbour. Sick.
                              ·
                            • PEN15Linda C
                              I never said that you said trans women did this. I addressed your argument that a male pedophile could dress as a trans women. I made that very clear. It’s the same argument that bigots ALWAYS use. I’m quite familiar with it because they repeat it over and over and it’s so far fetched and ridiculous. It would be funny if it wasn’t so offensive and easy to dispel because there is just no firm proof that it has ever happened. And if you’re saying it did, go ahead and show me the proof that pedophiles who were dressed as women were in girl toilets and change rooms. And what offences did they commit while in there? What were they charged with? Where and when did this happen? Post the link to the article in your reply if you are able to do that.
                              ·
                            • Linda CPEN15
                              You can put your head in the sand and say it does not happen but sadly it does. I am not a bigot but I am a realist. It is happening in many countries, UK, Australia, USA, you name it. I have put a full stop to this discussion now as I think everyone has had their viewpoint shown. You can believe what you like or not. That is up to you. I put a discussion here for people to comment on and I think I have achieved a very good discussion group. Whether you agree with the comments is neither here nor there. The discussion was put out there which I think is always a positive.
                              ·
                            • PEN15Linda C
                              True. Whether I agree or not is neither here nor there. The facts are what is relevant. In Australia, the UK, and the USA there are no verified reports of it happening. It’s not happening everywhere. It’s just false to claim it is. And when you spread that claim you are just helping the bigots with their anti-trans agenda.
                              ·
                            • Linda CPEN15
                              Again I am not anti trans so do not put this to me as a truth. I am anti paedophiles and there are plenty of news reports regarding this.
                              ·
                            • PEN15Linda C
                              I cannot find one news report. Not one. Never called you anti trans, but I wonder why if you’re so pro trans you would continue to spread this rubbish? You’re the one telling me there are plenty of news reports, so show me them because I can’t find any. Pedophiles disguise themselves as priests and scout leaders, they want to appear to be nice guys. I even know one personally who was working with a group of people that helped sexually abused minors through the court process. These people have more access to kids than a trans woman would in a public bathroom, and there is plenty of not only credible stories but convictions associated with these types offenders. These are easy to find with a quick google. So why can’t I find any reports/convictions from pedophiles dressed as trans women offending in a bathroom?
                              ·
                            • YankeePEN15
                              Since the so called elites want to spread division and are so obsessed with equality there is a really simple solution to all this. Totally eliminate seperate facilities Start with the top. No seperate facilities for any elected member of parliament at first and then work the way down through the society. Next get rid of all single sex schools and make all the facilities open to everyone. Just think how much we could save in construction and cleaning costs. No more male or female janitors need be specified. I wonder if those elites would mind having their daughter changing and showering with boys and men? Nah, no problem, right. Make everyone totally equal. No men's sports and no women's sports. Just sports open to all regardless. Make all military positions open to anyone. Everyone should have the right to die for their country too.
                              ·
                          • Pat C 618241
                            At last. we are finally getting some "adult" themes. When I first found this survey it seemed to be full of fluffy duck ideas. I don't mind disagreeing with the authors, it's a great idea to let it all out for public discussion. Some of us haven't had the opportunity to hear the variety of ideas now coming forward. As long as we do remember our manners as well!
                            ·
                            • Lee b 979050
                              Only one flag it's the Australian flag
                              ·
                              • allin
                                and on and on and on,,,, ain't this just about run the mill,,,
                                ·
                                • pam rae
                                  TY K 1364233
                                  ·
                                  • APB
                                    I must stress that if your PC does go mad there are other operating systems that are far better than windows...the easy answer is just buy a mac...
                                    ·
                                    • View all 3 replies
                                    • Linda C
                                      PC as in Political Correctness not a Personal Computer. lol
                                      ·
                                    • APBLinda C
                                      I know Linda..just having a bit of fun!...great discussion page by the way...love it!
                                      ·
                                    • Linda CAPB
                                      Thanks. Some people went a bit too far but yes it is a good discussion. Getting other views always helps one to understand more.
                                      ·
                                  • Bugalugs
                                    Political Correctness has gone stark, raving, mad. We are not allowed to criticise anyone or anything they do. In some countries, for a long time now and increasingly in others it is a Crime to criticise the Government, the President, the King/Queen, politicians or anyone in any senior position.We are expected to show Respect to those who have not earned it, yet when it suits them they can criticise, condemn us then, when challenged, they claim they are "Exercising their Right to Freedom of Speech" - something they would deny us! National Flags and those of other minority groups, not just the Rainbow one, should not be put on Children's clothing. Children should not be abused by teachers, parents and other into becoming involved in politics until they are old enough to understand and decide for themselves what they believe in. If these absurd people whole class themselves as being "WoKe" - whatever that nonsense means, and others had their way they would probably say "God forbid that Children should be allowed to be Children!"
                                    ·
                                    • roger b 167654
                                      If you had read up about it, you would know that the children have not been abused by teachers or parents into this - it was their own decision and one that's optional. This is a secondary school, so many of the children are only a year or so away from voting - so should be getting involved in politics. Maybe it's better to take a stand on something rather than being a walking billboard doing the advertising for some big multi-national corporation.
                                      ·
                                  • Thomas (Rewardia Support)
                                    Dear Rewardians. Please, be patient, tolerate and charitable. Do not post impolite, rude or offensive comments. Everyone on this forum boards are here to have a good time.
                                    ·
                                    • Peter T 100083
                                      Yes, as hate to see them closed because of a few.
                                      ·
                                    • Gunter L
                                      Hear, hear!
                                      ·
                                  • BLACK LIVES MATTER
                                    it is a very thin line between freedom of speech and hate speech
                                    ·
                                    • View all 7 replies
                                    • Thomas (Rewardia Support)
                                      Dear members. Please, calm down. Be respectful to other members at all times. We want to make sure that Rewardia Community has the ability for everyone to have a safe, positive, and inclusive experience.
                                      ·
                                    • BLACK LIVES MATTERThomas (Rewardia Support)
                                      I stated my opinion without crossing any lines or being aggressive. I am confused?
                                      ·
                                    • Thomas (Rewardia Support)BLACK LIVES MATTER
                                      No, you didn't cross the line. We just ask you to be a little more tolerated. Be positive. Bear things calmly.
                                      ·
                                    • APBThomas (Rewardia Support)
                                      it's tolerant...there is no bear in there....whether BLM is tolerated is something that he is unable to control...and of course he is!! we miss you Thomas
                                      ·
                                    • Liane H APB
                                      There IS a bear in there... It's not waving an aboriginal or rainbow flag ,yet it doesn't seem to mind others celebrating life a bit.
                                      ·
                                    • BLACK LIVES MATTERAPB
                                      I could psychoanalyze you - BUT - I don't have a PH. D in Human Behavior - however, I hope it makes you feel better!
                                      ·
                                    • APBBLACK LIVES MATTER
                                      I was sticking up for you...read it again...
                                      ·
                                  • Janet H 854956
                                    I ask WHY as well!
                                    ·
                                    • pam rae
                                      ty Dazzlejazz
                                      ·
                                      • Israt J
                                        The LGBTQ ruin everything
                                        ·
                                        • View all 5 replies
                                        • Linda C
                                          No I cannot agree with that but there are too many of the few having too loud a voice and expecting everyone to do their bidding.
                                          ·
                                        • Tom S QldLinda C
                                          I recently read an article about a Melbourne Uni professor who has been seriously hassled, abused and heckled by LGBTQ people, because she is lecturing about the history of the 'female movement', women's rights etc... The protestors wanted her to be shut down and sacked from the Uni because she doesn't acknowledge trans people as being part of the female world. The Uni didn't want to upset the trans people, so they asked her to change her lectures. She refused. The Uni then decided that she was the problem, but that she needed protection from 'the mob', so they hired 12 security guards and asked the police to attend, so that the people going to her lectures would be safe. The police decided to investigate and found that it was 5 trans people causing all the problems, nobody else. The Uni was informed but declined to press charges etc... The lectures continue, the security guards are still in place, the police decline to attend. The 5 trans people attend her lectures, yell abuse at her and heckle her, but are not stopped. Slowly, but surely, students are leaving her lectures. In the end it will just be her, the 5 trans people and 12 security guards. The Uni says that the trans/LGBTQ have a right to freedom of speech and expression. Apparently, the Uni professor doesn't. PC gone mad.
                                          ·
                                        • Linda CTom S Qld
                                          Unfortunately, these few types of protestors are becoming the norm and others are not allowed to say boo. They are not winning any favours either.
                                          ·
                                        • Israt JLinda C
                                          The LGBTQ community is also targeting people religions because at my sons school they completely scold him for not supporting it .
                                          ·
                                        • Linda CIsrat J
                                          That is not right nor helpful to the different communities. Personally I think each to their own but I do not wave a flag or march because I am straight and feel the same should go for others. Equality should be just that.
                                          ·
                                      • pam rae
                                        hi ty susan
                                        ·
                                        • roger b 167654
                                          I think we're all missing the main point - $98 for a public school puffer jacket - that's a lot to ask in these tough times! It's also a secondary school, not a primary school as Linda C states in her rant.
                                          ·
                                          • Liane H
                                            $89.95 actually. Yes still a bit steep. And correct a public Secondary College. Cheltenham Vic
                                            ·
                                          • Linda C
                                            Sorry I thought is was a primary school. However, I do not think I was ranting. I was putting an issue forward for people to comment on and many have done exactly that. So, I think a good subject.
                                            ·
                                        • pam rae
                                          sad what's going on, woke needs to go away...!!!!
                                          ·
                                          • JANET R 328390
                                            I totally agree with you. I see manipulation.........
                                            ·
                                            • Biscuit
                                              If it’s optional and you don’t like it, don’t buy it. It’s available for those who want to. If you’re passionate about having a jacket with the Australian flag then advocate for one to be available as well as this one. You’ve drawn a long bow between your dislike of a flag on a jacket and paedophiles in toilets, children being manipulated and women being marginalised ?? The jacket is harmless. Some attitudes however are not.
                                              ·
                                              • View all 14 replies
                                              • Liane H
                                                Exactly ,some of these kids may just come from gay parent families or have a trans sibling and are just supportive of them. How many paedophiles are heterosexual and often even fathers ? Statistics show many ,many.
                                                ·
                                              • Linda CLiane H
                                                I agree paedophiles are often family members etc. but I am concerned about these men dressing as women and being allowed into female change rooms, toilets etc. I was watching a report on just one state in the USA who have proof this is happening and females are being raped, bashed, and children are being flashed etc. many times. However, I was generalising how things have gone too far. I voted for Gay marriage and have friends and family members who are gay but that is not my concern. Politicising it in our schools etc. is not something I can agree with. Yes some children have gay parents and if they want to wear a flag then that is their prerogative but making it part of a uniform is not going down the right track in my opinion. One cannot buy this jacket without the flag. A lighter top is available yes but I am sure the kids would prefer the warmer cooler jacket. If I wanted to protest and take the flag off and put the Australian flag on I would not be allowed. That I see as political manipulation.
                                                ·
                                              • BiscuitLinda C
                                                It’s not politicising by having it available as an optional choice of uniform. From all accounts the students gave it the ok to go ahead. No one is forcing anyone to wear it. I’m sure there are alternative warm jackets to choose from. Nothing about this is political manipulation or threatening to anyone. Your concern over men dressing as women and raping and bashing women in toilets is quite a separate issue. This is a small emblem on an OPTIONAL jacket at a secondary school representing pride and inclusion. Nothing more.
                                                ·
                                              • Liane H Biscuit
                                                Agree there Bette. A group of students and parents on the school committee along with the principle to be precise ,yep. I think seeing politics in a tiny rainbow is kind of odd myself ,so I guess I will have to agree to disagree with Linda on this occasion.Whilst we all have to vote soon on the voice to parliament re the aboriginal people's representation to our country's policies why is that not the political stance here rather than LGTBQI ? In fact regardless of either i'm not sure why just being born the way you are is a such an issue for people on here . As for the men abusing the dress code in bathrooms etc . There will always be evil in all walks, that will take a loophole and make things difficult for the innocent to progress.
                                                ·
                                              • Linda CLiane H
                                                I do not think as this is a discussion group from many countries that The Voice is an issue for them. I agree there are and will always be evil men and women also but why give them to opportunities to instil themselves into vulnerable peoples lives.
                                                ·
                                              • Liane H Linda C
                                                And neither is wearing the aboriginal flag going to be an issue for any other country on this forum , yet it's also one that can't be removed or covered over on the jacket. The separate issue of people taking advantage of dress codes AKA men dressing as women and abusing women in bathrooms ( so straight men) most likely , I can't answer. I do say this though ,if you were a young 14yr old very gentle natured shy male that was on female hormones ,hated his own body and prayed each day just to be a girl and be accepted as one ,would you feel comfortable standing at a urinal with a bunch of loud rough housing boys ? Is that trans child allowed to have an opportunity this lifetime to go and pee somewhere they feel safe to do so? Most likely they're friends with girls more than boys at the school and would go in together.Change has to start somewhere Linda.. it is 2023 .. :) scary as it may be for some . Hell we still have to gain equal pay for women but that's another gnarly topic for another day.
                                                ·
                                              • BiscuitLiane H
                                                Hear hear 😊👍🏻
                                                ·
                                              • Linda CLiane H
                                                Yes there are a lot of topics that need peoples views aired. I know you say the trans boy would feel uncomfortable but there are many girls and women who feel very uncomfortable with a teen or a grown man with all his tackle entering their domain and they cannot say no. Maybe we need a separate area for them and then perhaps everyone will feel comfortable. I have no idea how to solve this problem but it is all going forward way too fast for it to sit right with me. It is like everyone is in a rush to look like they are forward thinking and inclusive when as you read posts on this site that is not the case at all. As I said previously, everyone needs to take a breath and set things in motion with a lot of thought and consideration for everyone behind every decision.
                                                ·
                                              • Liane H Linda C
                                                A lot of considerations yes ,these people need the dignity they deserve . As a note it was 1994 when the human rights act decriminalised homosexuality across all states in Australia. Some states such as Victoria were earlier 1981..This is now 2023 , and all different types of individuals ( which probably have always existed) are now slowly becoming free to tell their truth. Some never do . I'm not sure what the' rush' is I'm sure most have died waiting to just be heard ..It's very sad
                                                ·
                                              • Linda CLiane H
                                                And many women, children, etc. have been sexually assaulted by the opportunists. This is where the problem lies.
                                                ·
                                              • Teri 1282723Linda C
                                                Linda, I don't know if you're willing to get involved in pushing this forward, but in Canada, we have many places that now have Men, Women, and Family washrooms. These 3 options give everyone the ability to pick which washroom they feel safest going into. The Family one is normally a single-toileted room with a change station for a baby and you can lock the door. That locked door is the safety feature that attracts a lot of people; myself included and I'm a straight woman. Maybe you can get something going with your local government or shoot for the top officials and get petitions started to get these washrooms mandatory in places of government and business.
                                                ·
                                              • Linda CTeri 1282723
                                                We have had Mothers rooms for years. These are for the mothers and babies of course. We also have facilities for disabled persons.
                                                ·
                                              • Teri 1282723Linda C
                                                Maybe what you call Mothers washrooms should be re-named as Family rooms. I've seen a man take his son, maybe 4 years old, into the Family washroom and I was as happy as he was that he had that option. I used it when they came out. I think Mothers on the door would stop others who would really prefer to use it from going in. It's really sad how a natural bodily function is so complicated.
                                                ·
                                              • Linda CTeri 1282723
                                                I think some call them parents rooms, others mothers rooms, etc. Been many years since I used one so not sure of the actual names now. I am sure they have become politically correct.
                                                ·
                                            • Peter T 100083
                                              PC crap gets me so mad. I tell it how it is and brutally honest!
                                              ·
                                              • allin
                                                i am surprised the in the year 2023, there are still so many people with hundred year old minds, people are different, people don't choose to be different, they are genetically different,, y'all are just intolerant of anybody, anything, that you may perceive in your tiny brain as being different, let me ask y'all a question, if you were in a battle, and a gay soldier took a bullet for you, what would you call him then,,,, people are different, get with the program,,,,
                                                ·
                                                • allin
                                                  maybe it's time you left me alone,,, and go find someone else to bother
                                                  ·
                                              • Teri 1282723
                                                Linda C., you and others like you are exactly why things like this are being done. We need to teach our kids, whatever their ages, that there are people different from the ones you teach them to accept and care for. Plus, Liane H. describes this jacket in a lot more detail than you have. It says a lot about acceptance and doing your best. Plus, it's optional whether to buy it or not. I believe we all must accept and appreciate the differences in those around us....whether colour, religion, sexual identity/orientation, age, etc. We are all created equal, nobody is better than anybody else. LGBTQ+ people do not decide to be in their community - they just are. I know some people experiment just for fun, or out of confusion, but the vast majority are born who they are; just like you were born as you are. People like you are so judgmental and missing out on some of the best relationships they could have had because of your far-right-extremism closes those doors. I can only imagine the pain and loneliness of someone born into the wrong sexed body. Or a young person afraid of being disowned for revealing their true self, or shot or beaten to death because of who they love. Or going to Hell if they're gay because that's what they're taught in church. Or being shot up in a nightclub. There is so much fear of not being accepted that many suffer in silence. AND THIS IS WHY THESE JACKETS ARE SHOWING THEM THEY ARE LOVED AND ACCEPTED FOR WHO THEY ARE!! The woke movement has NOT gone too far; we are just getting started in educating closed-minded people like you. And your kids are learning to be better humans than you've taught them to be. Your far-right extremism makes us wonder what ever happened to love your neighbour as yourself and treat others the way you want to be treated?
                                                ·
                                                • View all 12 replies
                                                • Linda C
                                                  I an not a far right extremist and if you are just getting started in educating us 'closed minded people' I fear for our society. You are the far right leftist extremist I am guessing. I agree there have been some terrible historical incidences against the gay community which I never agreed with. I voted for gay marriage so see myself as at least slightly enlightened. How dare you judge me as not teaching my children to accept everyone - I did and they do. It shows you are very judgemental. If you read my post you will note I have cousins and friends who are gay and I worked with and employed gay people on their abilities not their preferences. Grow up and look at all people without your narrow minded views.
                                                  ·
                                                • JANET R 328390Linda C
                                                  I agree with you Linda. Well said.
                                                  ·
                                                • roger b 167654Linda C
                                                  I really think you are guessing wrong, Linda C, if you think someone is a 'far right leftist extremist' - did you even review what you wrote? How would that be possible - they're at opposite ends of the political spectrum. It would be like saying someone is a peaceful warmonger!
                                                  ·
                                                • Linda Croger b 167654
                                                  I was replying to Teri who I quote wrote "Your far-right extremism etc" and that he is just getting started in educating closed minded people like me. He also mentioned my kids are learning to be better humans than I have taught them to be. I think he was rather rude. Instead of giving responsible replies he hit the insult button. Hence my reply that perhaps he is a far right leftist extremist.
                                                  ·
                                                • Teri 1282723roger b 167654
                                                  Saw her reply to you; flew right over, didn't it?
                                                  ·
                                                • roger b 167654Teri 1282723
                                                  Yes, right over - missed my point entirely - what is a far right leftist extremist? Often people get outraged inversely to the effect that these issues will have on them - that is, absolutely no effect whatsoever, but will have a lot of effect on people who are on the arms.I also don't know why Linda assumed you were a male.
                                                  ·
                                                • Teri 1282723roger b 167654
                                                  Totally and utterly female here; I thought maybe she did it to make me engage with her?
                                                  ·
                                                • Linda CTeri 1282723
                                                  No just thought you were non gender.
                                                  ·
                                                • Teri 1282723Linda C
                                                  Seriously? Then why didn't you refer to me as 'they'??? Can we please stop this nonsense now? I really don't like our conversation and back and forth. We have differing opinions and that's that. Let's not get angry and pick at each other. Truce, Linda?
                                                  ·
                                                • Linda CTeri 1282723
                                                  I did not refer to you as they as I do not agree with these forms of pronouns in this context. Thank you for your opinion. I think this subject has been very interesting with many different thoughts on the matter. By the way I am not angry and sorry if you feel I have picked on you. Cheers
                                                  ·
                                                • Teri 1282723Linda C
                                                  Not at all. I felt that I was picking on you and that's so against my heart. I am sorry for saying some snide things and upsetting you. Please forgive me? I wish you well:)
                                                  ·
                                                • Linda CTeri 1282723
                                                  All good. Have a good day
                                                  ·
                                              • PEN15
                                                I guess I’m lucky that I’ve had a transgender friend from childhood and now in his 50’s I’ve seen what he has gone through his whole life, and he is so much happier now as he, than he ever was as she. This puts me in a position to be empathetic and supportive to the younger generation in the same situation. After seeing what he has endured and knowing that support, understanding and acceptance would’ve saved him a lot of pain over the years, I’m happy to see things like this happening now. A lot of people are scared of what they don’t understand, so I would suggest perhaps gain a greater understanding of this topic before speaking out against it.
                                                ·
                                                • View all 13 replies
                                                • Linda C
                                                  I have gay family members and friends and have been around transgender etc. for years. I agree things have improved and I am not trying to shun them but I also do not think the children should be put into new categories such as non binary etc. Respect yes but let us not go too far the other way.
                                                  ·
                                                • PEN15Linda C
                                                  People do still shun them, that’s the problem. That’s why I think showing them support is important. The kids from this school have the choice to buy this jacket or a normal one. That’s a choice they have to show support, they don’t have to do it, but they also don’t have to speak out against it which can be very hurtful.
                                                  ·
                                                • Linda CPEN15
                                                  It's getting better but there are some in this community that are not helping or doing the right thing. I never agree with someone having a cheap shot at another person whatever their preferences are, however, I still think all this is going way too fast and many people are getting angry at how much it has changed things i.e. even our laws have changed and if your work for the government you cannot use gender identity and in some cases can lose your job if you do. I am a female born and that is it. If I wish to call myself something else in my personal life that is my choice. But we have gotten off track. I do not think it is right for the jackets in school to have these flags on them and I also think if the indigenous flag is on them then the Australian flag also should be. The school moto is not the Australian flag.
                                                  ·
                                                • PEN15Linda C
                                                  I work for a government department. I have a choice to as to what pronouns I end my emails with, or to leave it at nothing at all. There has been nothing to say I need to change anything related to my gender. The only thing we have had to do regarding this is a module on how to be inclusive to minorities, basically how to be nice and accepting of everyone which is what I was taught at home as a child, but not everyone was I guess. Which is probably why they ask you to do the module. I think the media hypes up a lot relating to this as it is a hot button topic. Don’t always believe what you read I guess.
                                                  ·
                                                • Linda CPEN15
                                                  Not read but information from a worker who was told if she did use the gender identity she would be reprimanded and eventually if she did not comply would lose her job. Sometimes it can be an over effusive superior but I don't think so.
                                                  ·
                                                • PEN15Linda C
                                                  Maybe I’m mixed up here, but you’re saying your female friend was reprimanded for saying she is female? Or using the pronouns ‘she’ and ‘her’ Please explain further
                                                  ·
                                                • Linda CPEN15
                                                  When speaking to clients on the phone she apparently was not allowed to use gender identity i.e. is your child a boy or girl, etc. not use she/he pronouns either.
                                                  ·
                                                • PEN15Linda C
                                                  I’d love to see a copy of that policy.
                                                  ·
                                                • SmileyPEN15
                                                  If Linda's friend is a teacher, this could very well be true. My children's school staff are to address the students as "your child" or "they/their/theirs" when talking to parents or sending emails/notes to parents, unless the child/parents have asked otherwise. But it does seem that teachers saying "you/them" to children/students is becoming the normal thing now- in Public Schools anyway.
                                                  ·
                                                • Linda CSmiley
                                                  It is in a lot of government departments. I think you are gender born i.e. girl/boy. If you want to call yourself something different then that is your choice but I do not think it should be forced on others to use them if they do not want to. This is only a minority of people who do want non gender identities so why do we all have to comply with their desires. The Qld. government has also bought in non gender birth certificates etc. You can put whatever you desire on them. I think this is just ridiculous and PC gone too far.
                                                  ·
                                                • SmileyLinda C
                                                  You have every right to your own opinions as we all have to our own opinions. If you truly believe things are going too far, look into what YOU can personally do to try and change things then. Voicing your opinion here on a survey site won't get you anywhere near as far as joining a local community or political group who share your views. If you join a group in your local area, you may all be able to put your thoughts, minds and bodies together and reach other organisations who can help you. Unfortunately I'm not one who will back you up, but i will respect your opinion to think differently to what i do. I will continue to be an Ally for my non-binary (young adult) child, to my child questioning if she is a lesbian (who at one time believed she was tri-gender), to my best friend of over 25 years who had to hide the fact he was gay until he was almost an adult, to my online friends who are gay, trans, gender-fluid. Just because I am happy to be a straight female, it doesn't mean i can't support those who are not the same as me. The nastiest, most dangerous people i have ever met have actually been as straight as they come (and thinking about it, quite homophobic).
                                                  ·
                                                • PEN15Linda C
                                                  How does all this affect you Linda? If you find it difficult to accept then don’t participate. Don’t buy that school jacket, continue to assume that people’s gender is the one they look like, unless they correct you and go on your merry way. Being negatively opinionated on a topic that is very important to others, but probably does nothing to affect your day to day life is just bringing more hurt to a marginalised community.
                                                  ·
                                                • Linda CSmiley
                                                  People have misunderstood me. I am not against gays etc. I have many cousins who are, friends who are and I have worked with and hired many. I do not look at them as being gay though just humans. My point was that some questionable people are taking on the mantel of transgenderism to manipulate their way into the areas of our children/women being in sport or areas where women and children are most vulnerable. People have to stop taking it as an attack on them as a group. I am saying there should be a line drawn and separation should be paramount. A transgender changeroom, toilets, sports areas are not asking too much but the cost of course would be high but I do not think anyone should be upset with that. It is common sense. I have grandchildren, great nieces and nephews, nieces and nephews and I feel this issue does affect me. I do not want these children to face the same danger and issues my mother did and a few of my friends also. I agree these predators are in all walks of life but why give them carte blanche. Transgenders may have a few amongst them but the predators will take on the mantel of a transgender to infiltrate. If adults get hurt by us protecting our most vulnerable then they need to take a good hard look at themselves. SO, IT AFFECTS ME ......
                                                  ·
                                              • Liane H
                                                Respect,personal best,community, responsibility are the words on the front of this very optional puffer jacket chosen by the student's community. Along with the standard school logo. The standard jacket is also still available for those who wish to just wear that . This is a secondary college near me actually and not a primary school. I think the fact they have tried to make their students feel included and safe on campus as they go through the process of teenagehood( terrifying for some) especially if you're different is a good thing, however in their attempts to do this it seems to have raised more questions about others ideals of what's "normal" what's included.. who should MY kid sit next to? Oh that one's just pretending to be gay for attention.. a lifestyle choice.? get an education please. These kids have a high rate of suicide so maybe be thankful a small flag gives them some small joy and identity while they battle everyone else's intolerances and bullying.
                                                ·
                                                • View all 22 replies
                                                • Linda C
                                                  I really dislike the word tolerance which is so often used. I have many cousins and friends who are Gay, I have worked with and socialised with different gender identifying people also so I am not ignorant. I just feel it has all gone to far and in a very short amount of time. Putting a Pride flag on a jacket is not letting a person have the choice and for this I disagree not the fact it is there. If a person/child wishes to have it then that is his/her decision. Most kids could care less who sits next to them but as they get older such as High School things can change so it needs to be normalised from primary school and this is by just accepting each person not pointing out that they are gay, trans, straight or whatever.
                                                  ·
                                                • Liane H Linda C
                                                  I really dislike the phrase " lifestyle choice" or the really cutting one that these people are mentally ill. Now that you've explained a little further I do see some of your initial points ,but if you see the full article on this jacket, the flags are tiny.. on the sides of the arms and the STUDENTS initiated the idea.Most students are still choosing to wear the original item. Those that feel this new one gives them some form of identity/ respect for who they are either LGBTQI Or lndigenous ,or just a proud supporter of either , can wear it and still feel included as a part of that school. I'm curious as to what your gay friends would make of your opening statements to this, it sounded a little homophophic towards the end to be honest ,so that's why I would wonder.l just know a lot that have been and do go through terrible times and it's life long for them. A small everyday thing we wouldn't consider an issue affects them each day, different situations. .They often are reminded it's not right to be you. Don't hold your partner's hand when you go into that shop etc ,, make sure only these family members know who I am but let me hide from everyone else . They can choose a little bit of being themselves in a safe place at the school Mon- fri and hopefully find their tribe while they r there and get some confidence to get through the rest of this life that inevitably throws crap at everyone at some stage .Starting all this in primary school I don't feel is age appropriate .. That's one for the level playing field , with discussions in the upper grades in preparation for high school. As you say accepting each person but not pointing out gay / straight etc .. unfortunately those that are different will always be pointed out. It's human nature.
                                                  ·
                                                • Linda CLiane H
                                                  Does not matter how tiny the flags are it is making a political statement which should not be bought into class rooms of children. As I said I have no problems with the Aboriginal flag but there should have also been the Australian flag. Not all students initialised this just the few on some committee or other. Again, this can be discussed in class if required but being straight is never discussed is it. I guess I am looking for a balanced approach which I feel would be more beneficial and less divisive.
                                                  ·
                                                • Anna RogersLinda C
                                                  Exactly and perhaps they could’ve included an LGBTQ flag for those who wanted one as an optional extra. PC is definitely going way too far these days.
                                                  ·
                                                • PEN15Linda C
                                                  Being straight is the ‘norm’ this is the default setting in any discussion about differences regarding gender/preference. So of course it’s discussed. It’s the reason we have to discuss differences because they relate to being different to the norm! If you talk about balance, then you must realise that society is already tipped toward majority, so to put a tiny flag on a jacket is in no way tipping the ‘balance’ in favour of the LGBTQIA community. Straight people do not get discriminated against for being straight, so teaching people to accept straight people is not needed!! It’s trying to teach people to be less divisive. Your comments here are divisive. Putting a flag on a sleeve is how some kids are choosing to be inclusive. It warms my heart to know these kids did this. I just don’t understand why you would criticise the way these kids choose to support people that you also claim to be supportive of.
                                                  ·
                                                • Linda CPEN15
                                                  Actually straight women are now being discriminated against by letting transgender men take over their sports, allowed to enter female toilets and changerooms etc. Let me be a bit more specific. I do not think all transgender men do this but I do feel some very dangerous men do dress as transgender taking advantage of the freedom now allowed. We have to protect women now more than ever it seems and our children also. I am not totally against the flag but do not think it should be a fete accompli that it has to be worn. If one wants to put a pride flag on their clothes, car, home, etc. fine but I do not think it is right to make it part of a uniform which I might add you can not remove. Choice has been taken out of the equation. Yes you can opt not to purchase the jacket but in Melbourne it would be so warm and of course most kids would want one. I think the Australian flag should have been put on the arm. I am not critiseing the kids at all. I am against the choice being taken away though.
                                                  ·
                                                • roger b 167654Linda C
                                                  Isn't that exactly what you're doing, Linda C - you are taking the choice away from them by not allowing them to choose what they want to put on each arm unless it meets your strict moral code.
                                                  ·
                                                • PEN15Linda C
                                                  Choice has not been taken away. They can also buy one without the flags.
                                                  ·
                                                • Linda Croger b 167654
                                                  No I just think these political statements should not be in schools period.
                                                  ·
                                                • PEN15Linda C
                                                  It’s not a political statement. I’m kind of curious why school kids that live in a different state to you, doing something supportive for a marginalised community upsets you so much?
                                                  ·
                                                • Linda CPEN15
                                                  I am not upset about it I just do not agree with it. I grew up in Victoria and went to school in Victoria as did my children. Anyway, I do not separate Aussies by states. We are all Australian under the one banner. I just feel everyone should have the right to purchase this jacket and it should be optional and if they want the rainbow flag on it then they can have it. I still feel though the Australian flag should be on it.
                                                  ·
                                                • PEN15Linda C
                                                  It IS optional.
                                                  ·
                                                • Linda CPEN15
                                                  No the flag is on the jacket. It is optional to buy the jacket or not. However, as it is a pretty cool jacket and warm for down there I am sure most of the kids will want it.
                                                  ·
                                                • PEN15Linda C
                                                  Im pretty sure most of the younger generation have no trouble supporting causes that upset the older, more bigoted generation. Not referring to you Linda C, as you have stated it doesn’t upset you :)
                                                  ·
                                                • Linda CPEN15
                                                  Anyone can support a cause as long as it is their decision and I feel with respect to everyone and this is on all sides of the issue. I just do not think it should be a fete accompli
                                                  ·
                                                • roger b 167654Linda C
                                                  Why would they have to organise a festival? A fete would take a lot of organising and would all the parties interested be in attendance?. From what I read, it was a school committee. Usually these people are voted in or selected by the school, so I assume the buttons on the arms were not decided upon before the committee was formed - I assume there was much discussion and then agreement with senior school staff.
                                                  ·
                                                • Linda Croger b 167654
                                                  I never said they should organise a festival or fete? Yes a school committee decided the badges should be worn but that does not mean everyone agreed outside the committee are in agreeance. As per people in power everywhere such as governments etc. we might vote them in but not necessarily agree with everything they do or change or bring in.
                                                  ·
                                                • roger b 167654Linda C
                                                  If you read your post you will see it says 'FETE accompli'. That is what you wrote and therefore what I replied to. You've hit the nail on the head - we don't necessarily agree with what governments do, but we have voted them into power - if we want to change we can vote them out. We can't have a referendum for every decision that's needed, you have to get representatives to represent you.
                                                  ·
                                                • Linda Croger b 167654
                                                  Fete accompli means "it has already been decided or done and cannot be changed." Nothing to do with a festival or fete which is an organised event.
                                                  ·
                                                • roger b 167654Linda C
                                                  No, Linda - FAIT accompli means that. Translated from French it means 'an accomplished fact'. FETE accompli, as you wrote would have something to do with a fete, which comes from French, but means feast or party in that language.
                                                  ·
                                                • Linda Croger b 167654
                                                  No it didn't. I put it in the right context and if you look it up my meaning is correct. It means done and dusted. Nothing at all to do with a fete. How do you use fait accompli? If something is a fait accompli, it has already been decided or done and cannot be changed. Do the French say fait accompli?noun,plural faits ac·com·plis [fe za-kawn-plee]. French. an accomplished fact; a thing already done: The enemy's defeat was a fait accompli long before the formal surrender.Just plain FETE is a festival etc. but not with the accompli tacked on.
                                                  ·
                                                • roger b 167654Linda C
                                                  No, you didn't - you didn't use the correct term. The correct term is 'fait accompli' which means what you wrote. It is not 'fete accompli' that is not a saying and is incorrect. It does not matter if the accompli is tacked on or not, it is incorrect.
                                                  ·
                                              • Mopos
                                                I am surprised the Education Dept allowed this - if they are aware of this situation? "PC" is getting more scarier and idiotic every day! The mind boggles.
                                                ·
                                                • Andrew C 287196
                                                  It's a school uniform, so the *only* thing that should be printed on it is the school name / logo.
                                                  ·
                                                  • Linda C
                                                    Totally agree
                                                    ·
                                                • boy blunder
                                                  absolute bollicks or bollocks whichever applies, school uniform is about not sending messages is about leveling the playing field
                                                  ·
                                                  • Linda C
                                                    Happy to hear I am not the only one who thinks that. I think politicising our children is the wrong message. All this WOKE stuff has actually divided the people of this country and probably the world. Common sense has left the building.
                                                    ·
                                                • Chris M 626341
                                                  Madness!!!
                                                  ·
                                                  • roger b 167654
                                                    You’re quite right- it’s madness that anyone would take issue with an optional jacket - guess some people don’t want a kinder more compassionate society like these kids do
                                                    ·

                                                No comments
                                                AboutForumPrivacyUser agreementContact UsBusiness Page